The group is in the study room trying to cram for their Biology finals. Annie notices a moment between Britta and Troy as they are somewhat awkward around each other. Dean Pelton arrives in his latest costume and tells them that the exam has been postponed until tomorrow because Professor Kane is sick. Jeff suggests that they all take a three hour lunch break. Troy and Abed were planning on going to the Dreamatorium until Annie manipulates Troy and Britta into having lunch together at Señor Kevin's. In order to give the two more time alone, she asks to take Troy's place playing with Abed inside the Dreamatorium. The Dean then returns and admits he went too far with his outfit this time. Later in the Dreamatorium, Annie and Abed are playing Inspector Spacetime.
The Dean outdoes himself.
Abed becomes annoyed at Annie's attempt at a British accent and ends the game. Annie realizes that he's angry at her for playing matchmaker with Troy and Britta. Abed responds that he's mad at her for tampering with the fabric of the group. He claims that he's considered the possibility of Troy and Britta getting together from every angle, and she hasn't. He goes on to explain how the Dreamatorium isn't just a play room but also a way to simulate any possible scenario; he demonstrates this capability by acting out Troy and Britta's lunch date. Annie dismisses his portrayals as mere impersonations, prompting Abed to reveal the "engine" of the Dreamatorium. Located inside an adjacent closet, it is a cardboard "machine" which focuses Abed's thoughts. By using it, he combines his knowledge of his friends with logic to create objective observations.
The Dreamatorium at work.
When Annie says how ridiculous it is, Abed arrogantly replies that it's too complex for her to comprehend. Annie then receives a call from Troy on her cell phone wanting to know if Abed is okay. This further exasperates Annie who believes that Abed is being coddled too much. Another condescending remark from Abed pushes Annie to angrily rearrange the design of the Dreamatoriums "engine". Abed goes catatonic for a few minutes before starting a new simulation based on late night soap operas. The setting is "Greendale Hospital School", and Abed is role playing as Jeff who is playing the part of a doctor. Abed casts Annie as the love interest, the hospital administrator. She plays along to find the "real" Abed, who is missing. Annie has "Jeff" take her to see "Dr. Barnes" and "Dr. Perry" to help her search. After Annie injects "Dr. Barnes" with truth serum, he spills a possible lead.
New Dreamatorium location: Greendale Hospital School.
Annie and "Jeff" then go to the "Medical Study Room" for Abed's file. There, they find "Head Nurse Shirley" and "Alzheimer's Patient Pierce Hawthorne". "Shirley" tells Annie that Abed's gone because "nobody needs him". Annie gets "Jeff" to get the files by saying she'll sleep with him. The files reveal Abed is a patient which makes Annie demand Jeff take her where she wants to go. "Jeff" takes her back the end of their freshman year at Greendale on the night of The Tranny Dance. Having had enough, Annie tries to pretend that the files read that Abed is okay again. "Jeff" denies this by reading Abed's file which states he is a control freak with no empathy, and that people indulge him too much. "Jeff" then tries to hit on Annie, claiming that they can be together now that Abed, Troy, and Britta out of the way. Annie angrily storms off, only to hit the wall of the Dreamatorium and end the simulation.
Hitting the wall.
Annie tells Abed she wants to be alone, and he complies with her request by role playing as Annie. "Annie" questions why Annie keeps refusing "Jeff" who they love. Annie explains that what Abed is presenting, running the same scenarios repeatedly, isn't love but an obsession, prompting her to admit that she displays similar tendencies when it comes to Jeff. When "Annie" teases Annie about sounding like Abed, Annie is inspired to role play as Abed, which causes "Chang" to show up. He takes her to the real Abed who is imprisoned inside a locker. Abed explains this is where he spent a lot of time in junior high. He says that this is where people like him get put when everyone is fed up with them. Abed reveals he has repeatedly run the simulations, and he never amounts to anything.
Finding the real Abed.
She counters that his simulations are like science fiction: great stories but not accurate. They are merely his fears of being alone. Having those feelings is made easier by realizing everyone else in the world shares the same anxieties. Annie frees Abed from his fake shackles, and they simulate a dramatic ending featuring Blorgons. Later, the study group returns to the study room from their lunches. Everyone tried something different and had pleasant day. Troy apologizes to Abed for bailing on the Dreamatorium. Abed says it's okay and that Annie acquitted herself well in there. Dean Pelton shows up and says the people at the bank loved his outfit.
An episode of Troy and Abed in the Morning! featuring Annie giving interior design tips is shown. Annie reveals that she remade the Blanket Fort Room where Troy and Abed sleep, initiating another nervous breakdown for Abed.
Middle Eastern Magic 8 Ball: Abed role plays as a version of Jeff who does things only if Annie agrees to sleep with him. In the next episode, "Basic Lupine Urology", Annie ends up getting Jeff to show up to the Biology classroom late at night by sending him a misleading text that suggested she was going to sleep with him in the lab.
Also during the "Pascal's Triangle Revisited" Leonard scene, even if Leonard did somehow manage to beat Jeff outside (to witness Jeff's kiss with Annie) he was wearing a dark suit and tie, not a yellow shirt.
Recurring or debuting running gags in this episode:
Bag-ul: Annie mispronounces The Inspector's Quantum Spanner as a "Quantum Spammer", and also refers to Blorgons as "Blogons".
Bueller? Bueller? Bueller?: Jeff suggests they use their suddenly open schedule to take a "Three hour lunch? Three hour lunch? Three hour lunch?"
Butt stuff: Under the influence of truth serum, Troy, played by Abed, admits that he likes butt stuff.
Come sail away!: Troy cries while revealing his many secrets, which include crying during the soundtrack to "About a Boy".
Deanotation: Dean Pelton introduces his outfit as "the Duali-Dean of Man".
I'm Batman!: Abed takes on a total of nine different personas in this episode. Most are members of the study group including Chang, the Señor Kevin's manager and the Inspector. Annie finds only one of them attractive: Jeff the Surgeon.
Nice outfit: Dean Pelton even admits he went too far wearing a costume split down the middle, featuring one half wearing female makeup and clothing and the other half wearing male clothing.
“Can I be perfectly honest with you guys? I think I went to far with this one. I have to go to the bank today. What am I supposed to tell people in line? I had good news and bad news? Come on, Craig. Get your life together.”— Dean Pelton
“I love butt stuff, I hate spiders, I stole a pen from the bank, I cried during About a Boy...the soundtrack. I don't wash my hands before surgery. I can see why women find Clive Owen attractive to the point where I might just as well be attracted to him. I use comparisons to Hitler to win arguments on the Internet at the drop of a hat. I know nothing about wine. I'm more turned on by women in pajamas than lingerie; I just wanna know they feel comfortable. I didn't get Inception. I didn't get Inception! There's so many layers!”— Troy, played by Abed.
“Star Wars, Zardoz, Cougar Town. Cool, cool, cool. Pop culture, pop culture. I'm on a TV show. Meta, meta.”— Abed, played by Annie.
“The scenarios you run in here are like... great science fiction. They're impressive and detailed and insightful but they're not accurate for crap. Science fiction never has been. Look at 2001. Did we have a space odyssey? No, we got snowboarding in the Olympics and we over-validated Carson Daly.”— Annie